When
I first listened to this, the debut album by The Beatles, I used to think it
would have sounded pretty revolutionary at the time. In hindsight, you can hear
that it’s still got one foot firmly planted in the 1950s. Dylan followed Please Please Me two months later with The Freewheelin’ Bob Dylan, and that’s
like a futuristic text compared to the childlike nature of this album.
This album is notable for a few things. Firstly, the original compositions are
attributed to ‘McCartney-Lennon’, not long before the decision was made to
reverse the surnames. I heard a few years ago that McCartney was lobbying Yoko
Ono to get the rest of their back catalogue changed back to this original song-writing
credit. Thankfully it didn’t happen, and anyway, you never know if things like
that are even true. I wouldn’t put it past McCartney to try something like this
- he obviously waited until George Harrison died to release Let It Be...Naked - but you’d get the
impression that after 40 or so years, he’d be content that his name comes last
in 99% of their song-writing credits.
Secondly, the album was famously recorded in one day. I don’t really see that
as being anything special though. This happens for a lot of bands - especially
on their debut albums - and perhaps this should be a rite of passage for bands
recording their first batch of songs.
In terms of their song choices though, I do think that there are a few
mistakes. Their original songs really sound very good alongside some very odd
covers, but maybe that was the intention. There were better covers recorded
during the New Years Day 1962 Decca audition (available on Anthology 1), that would have fit better than some of the covers
here, and are closer to the standard of covers they recorded on their second
album.
Thirdly, Ringo Starr isn’t the only drummer on the album. He’d later be
replaced by McCartney on the occasional track later in their career, but here
he is replaced by session man Andy White on their prior single, Love Me Do / P.S. I Love You - both sides of which open the second side of the
album. George Martin had expected them to turn up to the session with Pete Best
(who had played on their first Parlophone session), had told Brian Epstein that
he wouldn’t allow Best to play on another session and that he would supply the
drummer next time. When The Beatles then arrived with their newly appointed
drummer in tow, Ringo was relegated to tambourine. If nothing else, this story
confirms that the band was right to fire Pete Best.
All in all, a very simple album that’s very hard not to like. Sometimes that
simplicity turns me off, but I also think that’s where most of its charm comes
from. The Beatles would produce works of much greater value and innovation, and
it wouldn’t take them long.
Hit: Twist And Shout
Hidden Gem: Baby It’s You
Welcome to Vinyl Stylus, a blog about good music, and what makes music good.
Here, you'll find Rocks In The Attic - a disc by disc journey through my entire vinyl collection.
In a world full of TV talent shows, greatest hits CDs and manufactured pop, take a stroll through something that's good for your ears and good for your soul.
Here, you'll find Rocks In The Attic - a disc by disc journey through my entire vinyl collection.
In a world full of TV talent shows, greatest hits CDs and manufactured pop, take a stroll through something that's good for your ears and good for your soul.
Showing posts with label George Harrison. Show all posts
Showing posts with label George Harrison. Show all posts
Saturday, August 11, 2012
Rocks In The Attic #122: The Beatles - ‘Please Please Me’ (1963)
Labels:
1963,
Bob Dylan,
George Harrison,
George Martin,
John Lennon,
Let It Be...Naked,
Paul McCartney,
Pete Best,
Please Please Me,
Ringo Starr,
The Beatles,
The Freewheelin' Bob Dylan,
vinyl,
Yoko Ono
Saturday, August 4, 2012
Rocks In The Attic #121: John Lennon - ‘John Lennon/Plastic Ono Band’ (1970)
Although
this album is starkly minimalist and deals with pain, anger and isolation, I
find it to be a really chilled-out album. Of the four debut solo albums by the
recently split Beatles in 1970, this is probably my favourite, closely followed
by Ringo’s Sentimental Journey.
McCartney’s debut is too childlike and home-made; and Harrison’s All Things Must Pass is too
self-indulgent, warranting a lengthy amount of time to sit down and listen to
it in full.
I can definitely imagine relaxing to this, with a joint, on its release - but like most people I would probably have been a little let down with its unBeatleness. All of the four albums are as removed from The Beatles as possible, with each member trying to escape from that shadow, but Lennon’s album sounds to me to be the furthest away.
Although McCartney’s album sounds like a hastily assembled bunch of demo recordings, Lennon’s album sounds more mature - and even though there is a very minimal arrangement and production, it doesn’t come off as sounding infantile like his former writing partner’s debut offering.
Hit: Working Class Hero
Hidden Gem: Look At Me
I can definitely imagine relaxing to this, with a joint, on its release - but like most people I would probably have been a little let down with its unBeatleness. All of the four albums are as removed from The Beatles as possible, with each member trying to escape from that shadow, but Lennon’s album sounds to me to be the furthest away.
Although McCartney’s album sounds like a hastily assembled bunch of demo recordings, Lennon’s album sounds more mature - and even though there is a very minimal arrangement and production, it doesn’t come off as sounding infantile like his former writing partner’s debut offering.
Hit: Working Class Hero
Hidden Gem: Look At Me
Saturday, July 21, 2012
Rocks In The Attic #109: Mamas And Papas - ’20 Golden Hits’ (1973)
It’s
funny that there’s a Lennon & McCartney song on this album - a very good
cover of I Call Your Name (in
addition to a cover of Twist And Shout)
- as Denny Doherty has a real resemblance of John Lennon, as the cover of this
album shows. And I guess John Phillips doesn’t look too far away from George
Harrison circa 1968.
I can’t remember why I bought this album. I guess with a lot of 60s artists, as it was a time before the LP had really become the in-thing, it makes a bit more sense to go for compilations over (usually) hastily assembled studio albums (which in most cases are simple compilations of singles and B-sides anyway).
I used to work with a guy in Oldham who was obsessed with The Mamas & The Papas. I never really saw the attraction really - although there are some very nice harmonies on here. I guess they’re a bit like a prototype Abba really, five or so years before that group hit the big time. Although if you were to go the whole way and change the name of the band to the band members’ initials, they actually sound more like a hip-hop group: DJMC.
Hit: California Dreamin’
Hidden Gem: Creeque Alley
I can’t remember why I bought this album. I guess with a lot of 60s artists, as it was a time before the LP had really become the in-thing, it makes a bit more sense to go for compilations over (usually) hastily assembled studio albums (which in most cases are simple compilations of singles and B-sides anyway).
I used to work with a guy in Oldham who was obsessed with The Mamas & The Papas. I never really saw the attraction really - although there are some very nice harmonies on here. I guess they’re a bit like a prototype Abba really, five or so years before that group hit the big time. Although if you were to go the whole way and change the name of the band to the band members’ initials, they actually sound more like a hip-hop group: DJMC.
Hit: California Dreamin’
Hidden Gem: Creeque Alley
Monday, June 4, 2012
Rocks In The Attic #49: The Beatles - ‘Beatles For Sale’ (1964)
The
fourth Beatles album - also known as the ‘haphazardly-put-together-between-tours-to-get-it-out-in-time-for-Christmas’
album - and for me, just as good as the albums on either side of it.I read somewhere that Eight Days A Week is notable as the first ever pop song with a faded-in intro. Now, I don’t know if that’s true - I’m sure whoever came up with that fact hadn’t listened to every pop song that came before this, but it does seem a little unlikely. Especially since the way recording had progressed from single takes into multitracking. With single takes, it’s far more likely that a song would be faded in at the start. Anyway, who knows? Or cares?
I sometime have great difficulty picking the ‘Hidden Gem’ on albums to detail at the foot of these blogs, but with Beatles For Sale it was too easy. The McCartney song What You’re Doing is so underrated - essentially unknown - that it’s almost criminal.
It’s also worth mentioning I Feel Fine (b/w She’s A Woman) which was released a week before this album - a great single, with a lead-guitar riff setting the template for rock music, and proof again that they were starting to get better and better at capturing the excitement of their live performances in the studio.
Hit: Eight Days A Week
Hidden Gem: What You’re Doing
Sunday, June 3, 2012
Rocks In The Attic #44: The Byrds - ‘The Byrds’ Greatest Hits’ (1967)
I’ve
never been a huge fan of The Byrds. I think it’s the heavy use of Roger McGuinn’s
12-string Rickenbacker. It’s funny that whenever you play a 12-string guitar -
electric or acoustic - no matter what you play, it immediately sounds like you
are playing something by The Byrds. Play a song written by Phil Collins and it
sounds like The Byrds’ covering a Phil Collins song. Play a song by Lady
Gaga...and so on.I remember buying this record on CD first - and playing it over and over again - probably looking for a substitute Beatles, and I suppose they’re the closest thing to an American version of The Beatles, or at least the two bands’ sounds are very similar through the mix-sixties period (Lennon and Harrison would play 12-string Rickenbackers on many songs throughout 1964 and 1965).
I like the way 12-string Rickenbackers are designed. The machine heads for the twelve strings are offset, so six are facing forwards, and the other six are facing backwards. Essentially it looks to the untrained eye like a standard 6-string guitar, as you can usually only see six machine-heads at a time. I think I read somewhere that this confused George Harrison when he originally saw The Byrds play live - how could McGuinn get such a rich jangly sound out of only six strings?
Hit: Turn! Turn! Turn! (To Everything There Is A Season)
Hidden Gem: So You Want To Be A Rock ‘N’ Roll Star
Saturday, June 2, 2012
Rocks In The Attic #38: Ringo Starr - ‘Sentimental Journey’ (1970)
I
bought this recently, really as research for a piece of writing I’m working on,
thinking it would be terrible, but it’s actually pretty good. This is Ringo’s
first solo album - the first Beatles solo album in fact, not including live or
avant-guarde releases - and is comprised of old standards arranged by the likes
of Paul McCartney, George Martin, Maurice Gibb and Elmer Bernstein. Mostly it’s
big band arrangements, with Ringo doing his best to croon over the top of them.This might give me a bit of confidence to listen to his second album - Beaucoups Of Blues - again, although I’m not sure my initial opinion of that will change much. Maybe it will.
You have to wonder what teenybopper Beatles fans would have made of this, and its country follow-up. ‘Disappointed’ is a word that I’m sure would have been bandied about. Three weeks after this came McCartney and that’s so home-made it almost sounds like a demo recording. It wouldn’t be until much later in the year, when Harrison released All Things Must Pass that one of them released something that sounded vaguely Beatle-ly.
Hit: Have I Told You Lately That I Love You?
Hidden Gem: Dream
Sunday, May 27, 2012
Rocks In The Attic #30: The Beatles - ‘Yellow Submarine Songtrack’ (1999)
It’s odd that they released this, as though admitting that
the original Yellow Submarine
soundtrack released in 1968 was a bit of a mistake. That album has four previously
unreleased songs of varying quality on one side, bookended by the title song
and All You Need Is Love; with the
flipside covering George Martin’s orchestral score for the film. Of the studio
albums in their official cannon, this has to be the weakest as half of it isn’t
them playing, and the rest is half-hearted, at best.
Released in 1999 to promote the re-release of the animated film, the Yellow Submarine Songtrack tries to wrong those rights by removing the George Martin tracks and filling the album out with the other Beatles songs that appear in the movie.
Hey Bulldog takes pride of place as the first song on the album (after the title song), and this was released as the only single from the album. Of those 4 previously unreleased songs that appeared on the original soundtrack, it’s clearly the best one - a nice little riff-driven rocker by Lennon that wouldn’t have been out of place as a B-side around the time of The White Album when it was recorded.
This is a nice addition to my Beatles collection - the tracks are fully remixed from the original multitrack tapes (something that they didn’t even do for the 2009 remasters), making it a pretty unique release. And of course it’s on yellow vinyl, and who doesn’t like coloured vinyl?
Hit: Yellow Submarine
Hidden Gem: Hey Bulldog
Released in 1999 to promote the re-release of the animated film, the Yellow Submarine Songtrack tries to wrong those rights by removing the George Martin tracks and filling the album out with the other Beatles songs that appear in the movie.
Hey Bulldog takes pride of place as the first song on the album (after the title song), and this was released as the only single from the album. Of those 4 previously unreleased songs that appeared on the original soundtrack, it’s clearly the best one - a nice little riff-driven rocker by Lennon that wouldn’t have been out of place as a B-side around the time of The White Album when it was recorded.
This is a nice addition to my Beatles collection - the tracks are fully remixed from the original multitrack tapes (something that they didn’t even do for the 2009 remasters), making it a pretty unique release. And of course it’s on yellow vinyl, and who doesn’t like coloured vinyl?
Hit: Yellow Submarine
Hidden Gem: Hey Bulldog
Saturday, May 19, 2012
Rocks In The Attic #13: George Harrison - ‘All Things Must Pass’ (1970)
This
is probably the most extravagant record in my collection - being the 2001
digitally remastered box-set. It’s a great album, and definitely the most 70’s
rock-sounding of the debut albums by the three songwriting Beatles.The first time I came across this album was when I was staying at my good friend Linsay’s house in Northern Ireland, and my other good friend, Kaj, and I were sleeping outside in the family caravan parked on the driveway. The only music we could find was the cassette album of All Things Must Pass, which we played all weekend, especially the jokey It’s Johnny’s Birthday - intended for John Lennon, but relevant to me also.
I don’t know what I like best - this, McCartney or John Lennon/Plastic Ono Band - but it probably depends on what mood I’m in. This album sounds the biggest of the three, no doubt due to Phil Spector’s heavy involvement (although he also co-produced John Lennon/Plastic Ono Band, he wasn’t around for a lot of those sessions, whereas you can hear his input all over this).
The ‘informal jams’ that make up the third disc of this triple album are largely pointless - and self-indulgent tossery - given that it feels more like a chance for George to show off his best-friend Eric, rather than to provide anything of substance.
It’s a shame that My Sweet Lord got a lot of undue attention because of its “similarity” to The Chiffons’ He’s So Fine. A shame because it’s practically the same song. Different instruments and different lyrics, but melodically identical.
Hit: My Sweet Lord
Hidden Gem: Wah-Wah
Saturday, May 12, 2012
Rocks In The Attic #7: The Beatles - ‘The Beatles At The Hollywood Bowl’ (1977)
I love everything about this album, from the hasty
introduction by Ed Sullivan to the constant scream from the fans which never
lets up.It’s a shame this album has never been released on CD - there seems to have been enough pressure for Parlophone to release the LP back in 1977, but this must have been regarded as a mis-step somewhere along the way as it now seems to fit strangely outside the official cannon of Beatles recording.
To my ears, this LP is just as important as any of their studio albums - if only as a historical document of the shows during the height of Beatlemania. The 2009 studio remasters would have been a great opportunity to clean the recording up a little bit more and place it alongside the other albums.
It’s incredibly short at only 33 minutes, but this is in line with the running time of their albums at the time. I love how they start Twist And Shout on the middle-8, and instead of playing the whole song with that section as the starting point, they quickly end it after a minute and twenty seconds, as though they had simply come into the song halfway through.
The liner notes by George Martin add a nice touch, writing a short history of how he was approached to revisit the recordings and produce the record. The only sour point is mention of the current teen heart-throbs of the late 1970s, The Bay City Rollers, courtesy of a comment from Martin’s daughter.
Hit: Twist And Shout
Hidden Gem: Help
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)



